7061 East Pleasant Valley Road, Independence, Ohio 44131 • (216) 241-2630 / Fax: (216) 241-6516

News and Issues
User Info

Editorial: Tennessee should get aboard high-speed rail

(The following editorial appeared on The Tennessean website on August 20, 2010.)

NASHVILLE, Tenn. — When the idea of an Atlanta-Chattanooga-Nashville high-speed train route was talked about publicly two years ago, proponents contended it should be given serious consideration.

A $1 million feasibility study that had recently been conducted on the Nashville-to-Chattanooga leg showed the project to be doable, but that it would cost an estimated $5.4 billion in public and private dollars.

Now comes word that Tennessee and Georgia's departments of transportation have jointly applied for $34 million in federal stimulus funding to develop high-speed rail service from Atlanta to Chattanooga, Nashville and eventually Louisville, Ky. The Federal Railroad Administration grants would allow the two states to continue environmental planning and engineering for a high-speed link between Atlanta and Chattanooga, Georgia Transportation Commissioner Vance C. Smith Jr. announced recently.

While critics probably will say this is a waste of time and taxpayer money, officials working on the project should continue moving forward with an idea that still is in its early planning and evaluation stages.

"We need to have more of a regional approach to connecting our transportation options, because the current system is not going to be able to satisfy future needs,'' Joe Carpenter, assistant commissioner in charge of the Tennessee Department of Transportation's environment and planning division, says. "Looking down the line, we need to position ourselves to have viable corridors that can support more movement.''

In other states, that is currently being done. According to the Federal Railroad Administration, Virginia recently began a new service to Washington from Charlottesville and Lynchburg that is showing 163 percent more riders than projected. An additional train is being added from Washington to Richmond.

Ridership is also reported to be up 25 percent between St. Louis and Kansas City, 7 percent between New York and Chicago and 12 percent between St. Louis and Chicago. The Federal Railroad Administration also said North Carolina's rail system, which will become a high-speed corridor in the near future, has reported 200 percent growth. In the West, the Amtrak Cascades route is showing record ridership between Seattle and Portland, and Amtrak's Northeast Corridor service has overtaken airlines for travel between New York and Washington.

Growth in auto traffic in China and India and the resulting increase in oil and gasoline costs provide a bellwether showing how expanded rail service will be needed in the U.S. in the future, Carpenter said.

"Our responsibility is to help educate the public on what the implications will be if we had a high-speed rail service from Atlanta to Chattanooga and on to Nashville. We can't sit back and do nothing.''

If we do nothing, Tennessee stands a good chance of being left behind as other states move forward in their different modes of transportation. And, as others have said, if we do nothing toward integrating our modes of transportation, we will only see our highways and airports become more congested than they are now.

Certainly, the idea of traveling to Atlanta from Nashville in only 52 minutes by rail sounds great. But as Carpenter said, it is going to take much more evaluating and planning to be sure that the idea is feasible and not a waste of taxpayer dollars. But if Tennessee sits out the process entirely, it risks being unable to get aboard in coming years, when the need for mass transit will be greatly increased.

Friday, August 20, 2010

Like us on Facebook at

Sign up for BLET News Flash Alerts

© 1997-2020 Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen


Decertification Helpline
(216) 694-0240

National Negotiations

Sign up for BLET
News Flash Alerts


Washington state will require a minimum train crew size
AAR reports rail traffic for March and the week ending March 28, 2020
North American carloads of motor vehicles and parts plummet
“May will be worse:” CN Rail CEO says Canada, U.S. just starting to feel impact of coronavirus
NS cautions coronavirus could impact financial results
CN workers fear risk from lax safety, sanitation on trains, in buildings
SEPTA seeks 10,000 face masks as pandemic continues to take a toll on transit service
Metra closing some rail cars to help stem spread of coronavirus
Federal charges filed by Teamsters against Warren Buffett-owned furniture firm
Brown appointed Director of NMB’s Office of Arbitration Services
Operation Lifesaver releases rail safety materials for news media
Q&A: Comparison of benefits under Railroad Retirement and Social Security
Coronavirus Relief Act impacts railroad workers
Get the latest labor news from the Teamsters

More Headlines