7061 East Pleasant Valley Road, Independence, Ohio 44131 • (216) 241-2630 / Fax: (216) 241-6516

News and Issues
User Info

More dogs working air, rail security

(The following article by Thomas Frank was posted on the USA Today website on February 19.)

WASHINGTON -- More bomb-sniffing dogs than ever are patrolling the nation’s airports and rail stations, and more are likely on the way as the federal government tries to blanket the nation’s transportation hubs with highly visible security.

The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) plans to add 45 dogs next year, primarily to subway and rail systems and also to the few large airports that don’t have them.

There are now 420 TSA-trained dogs patrolling 75 of the nation’s largest airports and 13 major transit systems. On Sept. 11, 2001, there were 174 dogs in 39 airports, according to TSA.

The TSA wants to make canine teams so prevalent in transit hubs that suicide bombers would believe they’d be caught before they could strike. “They have phenomenal deterrent value,” said Earl Morris, deputy chief of TSA’s office of security operations. “We deploy them so people know that they’re there.”

Dogs also can project a forceful image that reassures travelers. “For the public, they convey the message that security is happening,” Tom Farmer, head of TSA’s mass-transit division, told a recent rail-security conference. “They look good. They’re imposing. They inspire fear about what the dogs can detect.”

William Morange, security director for New York City’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority, said bomb-sniffing dogs “are probably the best technology out there.”

The dogs do have their limits, and some experts question their effectiveness.

A Homeland Security Department test last year in Atlanta’s subway system found that dogs grew tired after 45 minutes and needed air flow to pick up the scent of explosives.

“Dogs are relatively expensive, a lot of training is required, and there’s a very limited duration that they can work,” said Geoffrey Barrall, a chemist who led a group at General Electric that developed airport screening machines. “When they get tired, you usually have no way of knowing.”

Homeland security analyst Matthew Farr of the Frost & Sullivan consulting firm said dogs “don’t have enough of a presence to really be a deterrent. There’s a lot of room to expand their use.”

The TSA uses German shepherds, Belgian Malinois and Vizslas, and trains them at Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio. Some dogs are bred there, though most are bought from European breeders. The cost of housing a dog for a year and training it and a handler for 10 weeks is $25,000.

The TSA gives the dogs to airport and transit police, paying $40,000 to $50,000 a year for expenses and part of the handler’s salary. Dogs work 10-12 years.

The TSA wants to increase spending on dogs from $27 million to $30.5 million next year, using the extra money to supply more rail systems.

Transit agencies like using dogs but worry about devoting a full-time officer to one, said Greg Hull, security director for the American Public Transportation Association. “There’s a cost involved,” Hull said.

In airports, dogs sniff cargo, luggage, passengers and planes. In rail stations, they focus on passengers and their bags.

Morris, the TSA official, acknowledges that dogs have shortcomings. “Everything has limitations,” he said. “That’s why we build so many security systems.”

Tuesday, February 20, 2007

Like us on Facebook at

Sign up for BLET News Flash Alerts

© 1997-2019 Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen


Decertification Helpline
(216) 694-0240

Sign up for BLET
News Flash Alerts


AAR reports rail traffic for week ending March 16, 2019
Railroads’ flood-ravaged Midwestern tracks trigger FRA emergency declaration
Contractors, railroads battle catastrophic flood damage
Midwest floods stymie rail operations
Flooding cripples agriculture along Missouri River
Flooding bottles up U.S. ethanol
Cyber resiliency: A clear and urgent necessity for modern railroads
St. Paul-Chicago high-speed rail plans scrapped in favor of a second, slower train
NTSB: Impaired truck driver likely caused fatal Amtrak crash involving members of Congress
With its survival on the line, Amtrak shaves 15 minutes off Hoosier State line
Q&A: Longevity of Railroad Retirement beneficiaries
Get the latest labor news from the Teamsters

More Headlines