7061 East Pleasant Valley Road, Independence, Ohio 44131 • (216) 241-2630 / Fax: (216) 241-6516

News and Issues
User Info

MTA probes security on trains

(The following story by Herbert Lowe appeared on the Newsday website on September 8.)

NEW YORK — In the wake of its conclusion that Metro-North Railroad was too casual about guarding access to sensitive documents and areas, the MTA's inspector general has launched a new probe to see how well the LIRR and the Transit Authority are managing that task.

Metro-North's safekeeping of its operations manuals and thousands of door keys is far too lax given the ever-present concerns of a terrorist strike against a rail system, Matthew Sansverie, inspector general of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, said Thursday.

"What we're really trying to find out is, are there adequate controls over those items to keep them in the hands of people who should have them as opposed to people who shouldn't have them," Sansverie said.

Sansverie's concerns about Metro-North were outlined in a 12-page report sent to the agency's president, Peter Cannito, on July 17.

The inspector general's office began looking into the matter after a Metro-North engineer left his backpack behind on a train.

Police in Larchmont later found the backpack in an alley behind retail stores in that Westchester County village. A ring of keys that gave the engineer access to rooms and closed areas within Grand Central Terminal, controlled train movements and opened train car doors were missing, Sansverie wrote.

The engineer, Clifford Scott, a 23-year veteran of the agency, also reported that his operations manual and a general safety instructions book were missing from the recovered backpack, officials said.

Sansverie's letter also stated that Scott failed to report the loss to the proper authorities, and other Metro-North employees were likely being similarly careless.

The investigation also discovered that Metro-North produces more than 6,300 operations manuals when only about 1,800 of the railroad's employees are required to carry it, the letter stated.

In a statement released Thursday, Metro-North officials insisted that they take the threat of terrorism seriously. Merely having a train's key, it said, will not let just anyone steer it into harm's way, for example.

"In other words, a train cannot be operated anywhere the tracks don't go and where the signal and dispatching systems don't allow it to go," the agency's statement said.

Scott, who could not be reached for comment, will not be disciplined for losing the key or manual, according to Marjorie Anders, a spokeswoman for Metro-North.

"You can't punish someone retroactively," Anders said.

Tom Kelly, a spokesman for the MTA, said officials at both the LIRR and Transit Authority will cooperate with the new investigation. "Obviously whatever findings are reached in a report like this are shared with the other agencies and the issues are addressed," Kelly said.

Friday, September 8, 2006

Like us on Facebook at

Sign up for BLET News Flash Alerts

© 1997-2020 Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen


Decertification Helpline
(216) 694-0240

National Negotiations

Sign up for BLET
News Flash Alerts


Hoffa: Lawmakers must prioritize safety of all essential workers
NJ Transit workers fear for health as positive cases rise
Metra conductor tests positive for coronavirus
“They’re not taking our safety seriously:” SEPTA employees call for greater protections
Canadian rail blockades could have a lasting effect on U.S.-Canada trade, setting the stage for even greater fallout from coronavirus
Amtrak among companies cutting retirement contributions in the COVID-19 cash crunch
Analyst says “railroads are generally well-positioned; 2021 carloads will be strong”
Canadian oil company Cenovus further cuts 2020 spending, suspends dividend citing oil prices
Bakken producer Whiting files for bankruptcy
U.S. rail crude loadings tumble as prices decline
Overflowing oil tanks have traders eyeing rail cars for storage
NJ Transit uses coronavirus downtime to make progress on PTC
BNSF conductor says he was denied mask during desert sandstorm
Q&A: Comparison of benefits under Railroad Retirement and Social Security
Coronavirus Relief Act impacts railroad workers
Get the latest labor news from the Teamsters

More Headlines