7061 East Pleasant Valley Road, Independence, Ohio 44131 • (216) 241-2630 / Fax: (216) 241-6516

News and Issues
User Info

Illinois derailment highlights vulnerability

(The Associated Press circulated the following article on July 12.)

CHICAGO -- Everyone got out alive, the train operator did as he was trained and the passengers did as they were told. Still, that a small fire on a major commuter line could leave passengers gasping for air and send 152 of them to the hospital highlights just how vulnerable transit systems are to disaster.

The derailment and fire inside a Chicago subway line Tuesday came the same day massive explosions on trains in India killed 200 people -- a frightening reminder that there's no easy way to protect passengers on commuter trains, particularly those that run underground.

Officials and others say that after the last car of an eight-car train derailed, things went about as well as possible. They praised the train's operator for getting passengers off the train quickly and noted the orderly way the hundreds of passengers made their way through a darkened and smoky tunnel to an emergency exit.

''In terms of what this could have been, I think this was a remarkable achievement that they could get that thing evacuated with very few injuries,'' said David Schulz, director of Northwestern University's Infrastructure Technology Institute.

The cause of the derailment and fire was under investigation, but law enforcement officials said they had found no indication of foul play or terrorism.

The incident, which disrupted the routines of thousands of commuters, reminded many that train and subway systems have been far more seriously affected by terrorist attacks, such as those in London last year and Madrid in 2004. A suspected plot to attack New York's subway system was recently uncovered.

''One of the reasons, of course, terrorists are moving to trains is they are less protected, they are more open, there are systematic problems with protecting them,'' said Ivan Eland, a security analyst who is director of the Center on Peace and Liberty at the Independent Institute, a research firm. ''Also, airport security has improved a lot since 9/11, so terrorists are taking their attacks where security isn't.''

Such an attack was certainly on the minds of commuters Wednesday.

''People were thinking about anthrax and terrorism,'' said Yvette Mangren, who was on the train in front of the one that derailed Tuesday night. ''It's really sad our country and city has come to this.''

As she walked to work Wednesday, Mangren said the incident was especially stressful because as the smell of smoke drifted into her train car, the voice on the train's intercom said only that the train was stopped for a signal change.

''They're saying, `We're waiting for a signal change, waiting for a signal change,' and we could smell smoke,'' she said.

Chicago Transit Authority spokeswoman Robyn Ziegler defended the announcement, saying it was accurate and was part of a strategy to move trains into stations.
''Basically, what was done was done to move that train out and into the station, and that was done fairly quickly,'' she said. ''It was a tense situation, but we were providing information as quickly as possible.''

National Transportation Safety Board investigators on Wednesday interviewed the operator, the only crew member on the train, as the board tried to piece together what happened, said NTSB member Kitty Higgins.

The operator has worked for the CTA since March 2005, but Tuesday was just his second day on the line where the derailment occurred, Higgins said.

The train was too old to have a data recorder, now required in newer commuter trains, she said.

Thursday, July 13, 2006

Like us on Facebook at

Sign up for BLET News Flash Alerts

© 1997-2020 Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen


Decertification Helpline
(216) 694-0240

National Negotiations

Sign up for BLET
News Flash Alerts


Pan Am Railways goes up for sale
An observer’s view of the Pan Am Railways sale
NJ Transit claims “major milestone” in PTC progress
Amtrak to reduce New York-Florida trains starting July 6, with more cuts coming October 1
SEPTA Regional Rail is coming back, but many of its suburban riders are still working from home
Ports of Long Beach and Los Angeles set records for container movement
Nebraska Commission files complaint against railroads for blocked crossings
CN plans nearly C$1 billion in capital projects
Norfolk Southern sold its Roanoke headquarters building for $30 million, less than assessed value
Passenger rail between Duluth, Twin Cities hurt by lack of state backing
Port of Savannah calls 10% container volume drop “better than expected”
RRB begins paying CARES Act recovery payments for unemployed rail workers
Q&A: RRB reports performance under customer service plan
Get the latest labor news from the Teamsters

More Headlines